The Red Planet has always been a source of fascination for scientists and enthusiasts alike. Over the decades, Mars has offered glimpses into its mysterious past, with features resembling ancient rivers, lakes, and valleys that hint at a once-dynamic surface. These discoveries have spurred theories of liquid water flowing freely on Mars billions of years ago, drawing comparisons to Earth’s landscapes. However, as our understanding evolves, new theories are challenging the idea that liquid water was the sole architect of these ancient formations. Among these is the intriguing possibility that liquid carbon dioxide (CO2) may have played a significant role in shaping Mars’ surface.

This theory pushes the boundaries of our Earth-centric assumptions and opens the door to a deeper understanding of Mars’ geological history.

A Historical Look at Mars’ Surface Features

1. Early Discoveries and Assumptions

Mars first captivated humanity with its “canals,” famously misinterpreted by Italian astronomer Giovanni Schiaparelli in the late 19th century. Though these observations were later debunked, they sparked an enduring fascination with the planet.

When the Mariner 9 mission in 1971 sent back the first detailed images of Mars, they revealed a landscape riddled with dried-up river valleys and floodplains. These features seemed to confirm the long-held belief that Mars had once harbored flowing liquid water and possibly even life. This notion resonated deeply with scientists and the public alike, as water is fundamental to life as we know it.

Insight: The idea of Martian canals inspired early science fiction writers like H.G. Wells, shaping the way society imagined alien worlds.

2. The Role of Rover Missions

The arrival of rovers like Spirit, Opportunity, and Perseverance brought unparalleled insights into Mars’ surface. These rovers found minerals such as hematite and clay, which form in water, as well as evidence of ancient lakebeds and river deltas. These discoveries painted a picture of a wetter, warmer Mars billions of years ago.

However, not all formations fit neatly into the water narrative. Certain features—like massive outflow channels—suggested processes that might have involved other substances. These anomalies fueled the hypothesis that liquid carbon dioxide may also have shaped the Martian surface.

Fact: Opportunity discovered blueberries-shaped hematite formations, which were likely created in water-rich conditions, yet similar formations exist on Earth under extreme environments, adding a layer of intrigue to Mars’ story.

The Case for Liquid Carbon Dioxide

Mars’ Ancient Atmosphere

Billions of years ago, Mars likely had a denser atmosphere dominated by carbon dioxide. Under these conditions, CO2 could have existed as a liquid, particularly in the planet’s colder regions where the pressure was sufficient to prevent it from sublimating directly into a gas. This unique state opens up the possibility that liquid CO2 flowed across the Martian surface, carving channels and valleys similar to those attributed to water.

Example: Imagine a sudden release of liquid CO2 trapped beneath the surface, creating high-velocity flows capable of eroding landscapes within hours. Such events would have left distinctive marks, unlike those formed by water over millennia.

Geological Evidence

Certain features on Mars, such as streamlined islands and outflow channels, exhibit characteristics that are hard to replicate with water alone. Liquid CO2, being denser and more volatile, could have created these formations through rapid outbursts and erosion.

Fact: A study published in Geophysical Research Letters analyzed these formations and found that liquid CO2 could explain their abrupt and large-scale appearance more convincingly than water.

Laboratory Simulations

Experiments simulating Martian conditions have demonstrated that liquid CO2 can erode surfaces and transport sediments in ways comparable to water. These simulations provide strong support for the idea that CO2 played a role in shaping Mars’ geological features.

These experiments mimic Martian conditions using low-temperature chambers and pressurized CO2 tanks, showcasing how cutting-edge science bridges the gap between Earth labs and extraterrestrial terrains.

Challenges to the Theory

Lack of Direct Evidence

One major challenge is the absence of chemical signatures. Unlike water, which leaves behind minerals and hydrated compounds, liquid CO2 does not produce easily identifiable traces. This makes it difficult to confirm its role definitively.

Complex Climate Models

Reconstructing Mars’ ancient climate to validate conditions for liquid CO2 remains a significant hurdle. Current models often focus on water, making it challenging to isolate the effects of CO2.

The Dominance of Water Evidence

The discovery of clays and other water-related minerals strongly supports the presence of liquid water. Differentiating between features formed by water and CO2 adds another layer of complexity to the analysis.

Fact: Some scientists argue that a combination of water and CO2 processes could explain Mars’ unique features, suggesting collaboration between these substances in shaping the planet.

Implications of Liquid CO2 on Mars

Broader Geological Insights

If liquid CO2 did shape parts of Mars, it would suggest that the planet’s geological history is more complex than previously thought. Multiple volatile substances could have played a role in its surface evolution, requiring scientists to rethink their interpretations.

Impacts on the Search for Life

Liquid water remains the cornerstone in the search for extraterrestrial life, but acknowledging the role of CO2 forces scientists to expand their criteria. Could life exist in environments shaped by other liquids? This question broadens the scope of astrobiology beyond traditional water-based paradigms.

Example: Extremophiles on Earth thrive in environments dominated by substances like methane and ammonia, hinting at the possibility of life in CO2-rich conditions on Mars.

Revisiting Earth’s Geology

Interestingly, the hypothesis also prompts a re-examination of Earth. Could features on our planet—long attributed solely to water—have been influenced by other substances like CO2? This idea encourages scientists to look at familiar landscapes with fresh eyes.

The Future of Mars Exploration

Advanced Missions

The Mars Sample Return Mission, set to retrieve samples collected by Perseverance, could provide crucial insights into the composition and history of Martian features. By analyzing these samples, scientists may find clues supporting or refuting the role of liquid CO2.

Imaging Technologies

High-resolution data from orbiters like the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter will continue to refine our understanding of the planet. These tools can identify subtle patterns that distinguish features formed by water from those shaped by CO2.

Example: Future instruments may even detect subsurface pockets of CO2, providing direct evidence for its historical presence and behavior.

Ethical Considerations

Understanding Mars’ geological history is not just a matter of curiosity; it has ethical implications. As humanity contemplates terraforming Mars for future habitation, knowing the role of substances like CO2 could influence decisions about altering the planet’s environment.

Imagine a future where humans use CO2 trapped beneath Mars’ surface to create an atmosphere suitable for habitation—turning a challenge into an opportunity.

Expanding the Martian Narrative

The possibility that liquid carbon dioxide shaped Mars’ surface challenges long-held assumptions and enriches our understanding of planetary geology. While water remains the dominant explanation for many features, exploring the role of CO2 adds a layer of complexity that highlights Mars’ unique characteristics.

This theory not only redefines how we interpret Martian landscapes but also emphasizes the importance of questioning established narratives. As exploration continues, Mars will undoubtedly reveal more secrets, inspiring us to look beyond Earth’s paradigms and embrace the diversity of processes that shape other worlds.

Mars’ story is far from over. Each discovery—whether it confirms or challenges existing theories—brings us closer to understanding the Red Planet and our place in the universe.

What if Mars holds the key to rewriting planetary history? Discover bold theories, fresh insights, and groundbreaking science in our monthly magazine. Subscribe now!